Rami Ismail: risk-aversion is now the biggest threat to game dev funding ROI
Summary
Vlambeer's Rami Ismail led a DevGAMM 2026 workgroup arguing risk-averse funding criteria now cost more than creative failure
Balatro, Clair Obscur: Expedition 33, and Peak cited as hits no market analysis would have greenlit
Workgroup mixed creators, publishers, and investors - consensus that "safe" games underperform commercially
"The industry's fear of risk is currently the largest risk it faces"
01
Algorithmic funding criteria are misaligned with hit-making
Workgroup thesis: the industry produces its best work outside market research, not inside it
"Chasing the algorithm" shifts the failure mode rather than reducing risk
Games that "check all the boxes" were called "insincere, uninspiring, and uninteresting" - and commercially weaker
Funding models built on market-fit proxies may systematically exclude the highest-ROI titles
02
Three conviction-led hits no data predicted
Balatro, Clair Obscur: Expedition 33, and Peak named as evidence - all driven by internal taste
No standard risk-assessment framework would have greenlit these projects
"Courage is a consistent factor of most hit titles; in funding, in publishing, in marketing, and in investment"
Data is a validation tool, not a decision-maker - taste is what data cannot replicate
03
Four pillars the workgroup proposed for game development funding
Creating coherence: games must not contradict their own thesis - requires conviction and continuous validation
Identifying weaknesses at product, studio, and personnel level before they compound
Selling the dream: AAA and indie leads alike are failing to communicate vision internally and externally
Connecting the dots: structuring inputs and incentives so the first three pillars can function
04
Where conviction-led funding breaks down
Group rejected any return to "creative genius" structures - conviction without oversight produces its own failure mode
Taste is inherently divisive - courage-led bets carry structural audience concentration risk
Studios over-invest in validating ideas that do not fit the moment instead of cutting early
"The only thing worse than making a wrong decision is making no decision when one is needed"
05
Community traction is the strongest early signal for publishers and VCs
itch.io, Tumblr, and Reddit communities identified as more predictive than genre or demographic modeling
Recent overnight hits consistently had cultivated communities before major funding or marketing spend
Studios rarely ask for help when needed - a gap publishers and investors can fill as active partners
Actionable reframe: treat creative coherence and community signal as first-order funding criteria
Events
Companies
Games
Locations
—
COMPILED BY GAMES ATLAS EDITORIAL
RELATED ARTICLES
EXPLORE MORE
Comments (0)
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!