Mike Ybarra's "AI in everything" take backfires as players celebrate Crimson Desert AI art removal
Summary
Former Blizzard president Mike Ybarra publicly criticized Pearl Abyss for apologizing over AI-generated assets in Crimson Desert
Ybarra's "man up" comment on X drew immediate backlash, exposing a growing disconnect between tech-invested executives and the general public
Pearl Abyss removed AI placeholder art and updated its Steam disclosure after player outcry - a move widely celebrated by the community
"AI, in one form or another, will be in every single video game... Man up."
01
Crimson Desert launches to mixed reception despite strong early sales
Crimson Desert sold over 2 million copies but launched to criticism over gameplay, controls, and design
PCGamesN review described it as a "beautiful, shallow world"
Players later discovered AI-generated 2D prop assets embedded in the game
Pearl Abyss acknowledged the assets were placeholders and issued a public apology
02
Pearl Abyss responds to AI backlash with removal and disclosure update
Pearl Abyss committed to replacing all AI-generated assets through their standard art production pipeline
The studio updated Crimson Desert's Steam page to include a generative AI content disclosure
The disclosure was notably absent at launch just days before the update, flagged via Wayback Machine
"Generative AI technology is used in a supplementary capacity during the creation of some 2D prop assets. Any such assets are replaced through our production pipeline by our art and development teams"
03
Ybarra's "inevitable AI" argument lands poorly with players and industry observers
Ybarra, now CEO of a gambling website, took to X to challenge Pearl Abyss' decision to apologize
His post argued AI will be present in "every single thing - from video games to your fridge"
The first reply to his post read: "I'm so glad you're not ruining Blizzard anymore"
Ybarra's response referenced Microsoft Copilot in WoW - despite Microsoft currently scaling back Copilot due to widespread negative user feedback
04
Public trust in "next big tech" narratives is eroding
NFT gaming failed catastrophically after years of industry hype
Meta's metaverse was abandoned after Mark Zuckerberg spent $80 billion and rebranded his entire company around it
These high-profile failures are shifting public perception - AI risks being seen as another overhyped digital fad
Executives with financial stakes in AI adoption are increasingly viewed as unreliable voices on the subject
05
What to watch ahead
Pearl Abyss will need to demonstrate full removal of AI assets and rebuild player trust ahead of future updates
Industry pressure is mounting on developers to be transparent about AI use at launch, not retroactively
The broader debate on AI in game development will intensify as more titles ship with undisclosed generative content
Events
Companies
Games
Locations
—
COMPILED BY GAMES ATLAS EDITORIAL
RELATED ARTICLES
EXPLORE MORE
Comments (0)
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!